That was the title of an Op-Ed by Jon King in a site called "Michigan Advance," following the victory of Abdul El-Sayed in the Democratic primary for US Senator in Michigan. After reading the article, I thought it was a perfect example of those 45% of secular Jews who said they felt no connection to Israel. But words tell the story far better than a statistic. (See the 7/21/26 post "I'm Fed Up! Why Aren't You? Part I" for a discussion of the 45%.)
King: "I'm an American Jew, and my political loyalty is not to Democrats or to Republicans. It is to American democracy. Full stop." Nowhere in this Op-Ed did King happen to mention the name Donald Trump. But his numerous references to American democracy and a strongman seizing power, made it quite clear he was talking about Trump. I agree with his sentence, although I would have not thought to add the word "democracy" at the end.
King goes on to tell us that he was raised in a Jewish household, and celebrated the usual Jewish holidays, such as Passover and Hanukkah. Then he makes this incredible statement: "Israel matters to millions of Jews for reasons that are deeply personal and entirely understandable." Except, he does not appear to share the view of those millions of Jews. He explains: "But the United States is the nation whose institutions protect my rights, my neighbors' rights and my children's future." Okay. But is he unable to have feelings for more than one entity at a time? I'd bet he has feelings for more than one family member at a time. More than one friend at a time. Could that really be the issue? Or is he hiding something?
He then expresses his surprise that some Michigan Jews say that they will vote for the Republican candidate, Mike Rogers, over El-Sayed, because of El-Sayed's views on Israel and the war with Gaza. Finally, he tells us his true concern: "Jewish history is replete with examples of what happens when strongmen seize power." There it is - the not so subtle reference to Donald Trump. Trump was elected. Trump did not seize power. If King has Hitler in mind as the comparison to Trump, I don't even know what I might say to him. But I'd start with: "are Jews being rounded up and sent to concentration camps?" It is not an answer to say people here illegally are being detained for deportation. If I recall correctly, wasn't Obama called the "Deporter-in-chief?" Did Mr. King ever complain about Obama being a "strongman?" I doubt it. (As an aside, leftwing Jews are always surprised that any Jew would ever vote for a Republican. They literally cannot comprehend it.)
Here's the rest of Mr. King's concerns. After referring to his "Jewishness," which appears to be more cultural than religious, he says that it should not "obligate Jewish Americans to feel loyalty to a country they likely never lived in and increasingly may not represent the values they were raised with." And there's the rest of it. I have zero doubt that, as with many liberal Jews, King equates Netanyahu to Trump. And hates them both. Again, without mentioning Netanyahu by name. What values do you find objectionable, Mr. King? Does he accuse Israel of committing genocide? Of being an apartheid state? Is he upset by Israel defending itself after October 7, 2023, when Hamas committed the worst slaughter of the Jewish people since the Holocaust? Maybe he objects to Israel having to fight a multi-front war against Hamas and Hezbollah and the Houthis and Iran, all at the same time, and blames Israel for all of it. Because he appears to be indifferent to the survival of Israel.
Clearly, Mr. King feels no religious connection to Israel. Notwithstanding the thousands of years of connection of the Jewish people to that land. Notwithstanding that Jerusalem is where the two great Temples stood. Notwithstanding that is where our patriarchs (Abraham, Isaac and Jacob) and our matriarchs (Sarah, Rebecca and Leah) are buried - in the Cave of the Patriarchs. Notwithstanding the frequent reference to Jerusalem in our prayers. Okay, let's skip all that.
Let's talk about Israel being a safe haven for the Jewish people. Let's talk about how the Jewish people around the world celebrated the establishment of the Jewish state in 1948. Because, unlike you, they knew how significant a Jewish state was for the Jewish people. Israel has taken in Jewish people, not just from Europe after the Holocaust. But from all over - when the Jews faced persecution and expulsion from other countries. From all the over the Middle East, when the Arab countries either made life difficult after 1948, or expelled them. The tiny state of Israel also took in the Ethiopian Jews. They took in the Russian Jews. Not sure why I have to explain this, but when Palestinian terrorists hijacked a French airliner filled with Jewish passengers and flew it to Entebbe in Uganda, it wasn't the French who rescued those Jews. Nor the United States. It was the tiny state of Israel.
It isn't that you just feel nothing special for Israel. You said it yourself. "I wish the people who live in Israel and the territories it occupies ("occupies" is a telling comment right there) - Jews, Palestinians, Muslims, Christians and everyone else, peace, safety, and dignity, just as I wish those things for people anywhere." It appears that Mr. King not only feels nothing special for the land of Israel, and but also feels nothing special for the Jewish people. Which is ironic given his earlier statement about "strongmen seizing power." If that should happen here, where would you propose that the Jewish people flee to for safety, Mr. King? Not Israel, because in your world there is no Israel. Then where?