In an Op-Ed in the NY Post, a Rikki Schlott discussed the riots in France. Then she said that a French novelist, Michel Houellebecq, had been charged with hate speech because of things he said in 2022. concerning Islam and mass immigration. Such as: "when entire territories come under Islamist control...(violent) acts of resistance will take place." And this: "the wish of the population with French roots" is for "the violence to decrease, for (Muslim immigrants) to respect the law and people. Or, another good solution, for them to leave." One need not agree with this French writer to immediately recognize that he is not protected by the First Amendment, the way we in America are. Sadly, fewer people seem to appreciate the greatness of our Constitution.
And Schlott ended with this observation: "It's a disgusting inversion of justice - and an indication that a nation being torn apart from within is more concerned with thought crimes of its citizens than the actions of hooligans intent on destroying civilization itself."
Here in America, in my home state of New Jersey, Assembly Bill 1146 includes a definition of "Islamophobia." Language in the Bill includes: "rhetorical, violent, or physical anti-Muslim manifestations directed against Muslim or non-Muslim individuals, or their property, or Muslim community institutions and religious facilities." I understand about the violence. But "rhetorical?" I'm pretty sure that is protected by the First Amendment. As for "religious institutions," there have been too many instances of Imams advocating for violence against Jews and other Americans.
Also in the Bill is a provision discussing "expressing an outlook or worldview involving an unfounded dread and dislike of Muslims, which results in practices of exclusion and discrimination." Hold on here. Expressions? Worldviews? Protected by the First Amendment. And what does it mean "unfounded" dread? I can list dozens of attacks by radical Muslims/Islamists on Israel, on Jews everywhere, and on America and Americans everywhere.
After a certain point in time, I think we can say there is nothing "unfounded" about it. (For those new to the blog, I will repeat...I do not believe ALL Muslims are Islamists who want to dominate everyone else.) Of course, the Bill says at the end that all First Amendment rights are reserved. Sounds like people will have to fight for those rights based on what the Bill seeks to penalize.
Unfounded? It's been reported that an "Islamic scholar" and University of Illinois at Chicago student, spoke at an Islamic event in November, 2025. Said this scholar, as translated by MEMRI (The Middle East Media and Research Institute, an American organization that monitors reporting in the Arab and Muslim world): "We did not come here to coexist. We are superior to everyone else and will not be surpassed. No one is above us. If other religions want to live with us, they have to worship Allah."
Anybody want to tell me about unfounded dread?